Itialian and French World Cup Fiasco a Good Thing?

Just 4 Years Ago

Yes, its a strange question to pose.  And I doubt anyone in Italy or France would agree right now.  But I think long term this could be a positive.  Yes, even the French dramatics.  Both countries went into this World Cup with as many questions as hopes for glory.  And to be honest it could have gone either way.  Ribery could have turned into the next Zidane and could have led his team to glory.  They sure had the talent to go far, but shot themselves in the foot.  Italy was a bit more of an enigma.  There were questions about the selection.  After an uninspired European Championship in 2008 the old professor Marcello Lippi came back to regain glory for Italy.  And this was Italy after all, count them out at your peril.

But as with France the result was a total disaster.  Last place in their group, and a ticket back home in tears.  I am sure there are many rotten tomatoes awaiting the Azzurri.  We all saw what happened.  I documented the problems in the French camp here, even though there was a bit more handbags and one more terrible game to play before they went home.  But lets look at what they can learn from this and how quickly they can move on.

France

It Was In the Stars

The main problem was the French Football Federation’s (FFF) insistence in not firing Raymond Domenech two years ago.  Yes, it was that simple.  Yes they got to the WC final in 2006 but it was not through great tactics and system.  Zinedine Zidane took the team and the whole nation on his back and carried them to the final.  He inspired the whole team.  Only to leave the game in infamy after headbutting an Italian player late in the game.  It would have been difficult to fire Domenech then.  So they stuck with him.  But after the Euros in 2008 he should have been gone.  It was very obvious to everyone but the FFF.  Perhaps the stars said they will do well in 2010, but stars lie sometimes.  And its not as if France lacked great young managers.  Anyone managing Lyon was a candidate, so were the very bright Deshamps and Blanc (who was named as the successor to Domenech before this WC).  But leaving him and then announcing before the WC that he will be replaced was a stupid move.

And French football stars did not help.  The locker room became split.  No one able to step up, no leaders among great players and veterans.  France lost this WC campaign before they even landed in South Africa.  Plus I don’t think the way they got there helped.  Despite having one of the most talented teams in the competition they gave themselves no chance.

So Laurent Blanc has an easy job now.  Yes.  Despite the crushing way they went out, and despite the problems Blanc’s job was made so much easier because of those things.  Now even if he wants to keep some great players who are still young enough, like Ribery, out of the squad he has the perfect excuse.  He can make his own team.  One that will be indebted to him and one that will listen to him.  Pundits too will give him time, as will the fans.  The team must be rebuilt.  France has a lot of young, very talented players.  And once they become a proper team they can be a force in football for a long time.

It wont take long for France to become a strong team once again.  I think they could even be a force in the next European Championships.  And those ageing and whining stars just made it easier for Blanc to rebuild the team and do his job properly without much resistance from fans and media.

Forza Geriatrics?

Despite not being the oldest squad in the WC there were may questions about their age.  Especially about some of their important players.  Fabio Canavarro, the over hyped leader and captain of Italy in 2006 and 2010 is 36.  Well El Capitano has not played nay decent football since that World Cup glory in Germany.  Unfortunately Marcello Lippi paid no attention to that and stuck with El Capitano.

There were other question about the current World Champions and four time winners.  No leader in the midfield other than Andrea Pirlo who was injured.  Lippi’s insistence on not taking the enigmatic, but brilliant, Cassano.  Taking and not playing Gattuso.  Why was he there if he was not going to play?  Why not take a younger player who might learn from this?

Marcello Lippi left the job in glory in 2006.  Roberto Donadoni was chosen as his successor.  It was an impossible job.  So he was done after 2008.  But Lippi made the mistake of coming back and now leaves in infamy.  People will quickly forget his brilliant leadership if 2oo6.  And this time there was no Roberto Baggio who could lead the team like in 1994.  No one stepped up.  No veteran, no youngster.  Italy were uninspired.  Playing without urgency.  It was almost a mirror image of France, but without the visible drama off the pitch.  Last World Cup the scandal in Serie A helped the Italian Squad.  It brought them closer, it was them against the world.  Now there was no scandal.

Well the scandal was their play on the pitch.  Italy were traditionally slow starters.  So a draw against a strong Paraguay was not a bad result really.  But not winning against New Zealand was shocking.  And their performance against what till today was a very poor Slovakia side was disgraceful.  They tried for 20 of the 90+ minutes played.  A pathetic showing.  Poor and still unfit Andrea Pirlo, always a class act, came on in desperation to try to lead them to victory, but even he was not enough.  Silly give aways, terrible play in the midfield and defence, and inept attack did Italy in.

There will be no great drama like with the French.  But a lot of questions will be asked.  Cesare Prandelli will take over for the retired Lippi.  Like with Blanc, his job will be made easier.  No more silly expectations, no more old stars who can no longer play at this level.  A new Italy will emerge.  With younger players, with new leaders, new set up.  Italy also has many young talented players.  I am not sure if it will take about 2 or 4 years for them to be back near the top of footballing world, but it will be no longer than that.  Italians are winners.  New players will step up.  New Baggios, Rossis, and Pirlos will be found.  Prandelli will rebuild the team in his image.  He will utilize the players talents and mould the formation that will fit them best.  No more relying on past their prime old horses who can not play any more.

Yes its no consolation today for either Italy of France.  But the misery and shame will not last long.  Both will be back and soon.  So those despairing should take note, sometimes a revolution is needed.  And this pathetic showing helped make that transition easier.

Advertisements

The URI to TrackBack this entry is: https://rlisu.wordpress.com/2010/06/24/itialian-and-french-world-cup-fiasco-a-good-thing/trackback/

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: